Personal Project: Architectural Layers: Lighting For Post-Processing

Shooting architecture has always been a complex matter and while the challenges remain the digital medium has helped overcome many hurdles. Challenges such as color balance, lighting consistency, and the need to hide every single light and cord have been lessened. In this article I will describe one challenge that exemplifies how I now use digital to make images that would have been logistical nightmares in the past.

Layers and saved selections are extremely important to allow the refinement of the blending.
All Photos © Mike Butler

Having been a practitioner of architectural photography since 1994, I was trained in the “old world” 4x5 film protocol. From the very first days when straight chrome moved to scanned negative, a gateway to full digital, I saw the almost Alice in Wonderland down the rabbit hole possibilities that were overcoming the industry, namely the possibility that I could shoot multiple exposures with varying lighting setups and combine them later in Photoshop. In lieu of 12 lights, a case of clip-ons, and a few Fresnels, I could bring only three lights and duplicate those three lights into 100 if I so desired.

The total number of image captures, 167; images used for production, 34.

Over the years, starting with scans from 4x5 negatives, I explored the parameters and pitfalls of this technique. Although transitioning to full digital incurred a steep learning curve, I soon saw the savings in the cost of film and processing, the lack of requiring long exposure times of film, and later how HDR changed the way many architectural photographers work. Yet, I also saw how HDR lacked the ability to bring out texture and hues hidden just below the surface, a nuance that can only be extracted with a skillful use of lighting and Layers.

The most important step in postproduction is the raw conversion. It is here where the color and tonality of each image is refined down. When dealing with any space the color and tonality need to say very consistent, so when dealing with changing lighting conditions, it does sometimes take several conversions to get things just so.

The basic concept of the shooting style is this: given that the camera, fixed to a weighted tripod does not move and objects in the field of view do not move, it becomes a simple task of previsualizing the final lighting outcome, and shooting, say, three lights at a time, moving them to each area of the space. Each time this move is made it effectively doubles the number of lights used and the complexity of the shot increases proportionally. Through the years I practiced and refined this technique both on commercial jobs and on self-funded ventures. That’s how I worked for the Salmona Project, photographing the beautiful Virgilio Barco Library in Bogotá, Colombia, designed by Colombia’s greatest architect, Rogelio Salmona. Because of its massive size and Escher-like architectural complexity, it certainly offered up some unique lighting and logistical challenges. Yet, these challenges could be easily overcome using this hybrid multi-shot exposure technique.

This screen shot from the final image shows some of the saved selections used during editing. These 10 saved selections encompass about a third of the total; many selections are not saved because the work moves so quickly.

Preproduction
When looking at the Salmona space, a certain amount of planning was required both in terms of angles and the application of lighting, as well as how it all would be combined later in Photoshop. It was imperative for me to visualize the final lighting in a single shot execution. Although you can randomly put lights here and there with no logic, it is immensely better if you mentally compare the single shot lighting setup with the hybrid setup, looking for similarities and differences and how those can be bridged. My aim was to maintain some semblance of reality, even if that reality is totally manipulated. It is of no use after the shoot, while sitting in front of the monitor, to have five exposures with different lighting setups that do not relate to one another.

Here’s the layer composite of the initial shot.

I could tell right off the bat that the Virgilio Barco Library was so vast that using three lights at a time would be aesthetic suicide, as the flexibility of that technique would be totally outweighed by the postproduction. In short, the library shoot required techniques from both new and old world schools of photography. I would need to use the full allotment of lights traditionally required for a single shot, and because of the grandiose size of the spaces, implement that single shot lighting setup multiple times. Also because of the extreme logistics, I would need a full four-person crew along with a full maintenance staff and security if I had any chance of doing more than one shot a night.

After an eight-hour production and another eight hours of postproduction, the image emerges from its parts to reveal the previsualized concept, which until now resided only in my mind. Every section lit for impact creates an exponential result in a way that would be totally impossible without this technique.

Shooting
For the main exterior I stuck with Lowel DP hot lights for the simplicity and feel of the light. Just after capturing the dusk sky, I began the exterior shot by lighting a few main surfaces on the left side as a foundation. As the exterior shot progressed, these foundation lighting setups were moved so as to best implement a blending of planes. As I moved across the building, I noted that in order to blend the grass on the left side I would need to move from lighting the left background to a lateral foreground axis and continue that lighting using the small water effect as a termination point. I would use this termination point to continue and blend the lighting later when the right side background lighting caught up. Once the foreground was completed, I continued with the main structure, starting just to the right of where I left off, moving in a zigzag pattern, making sure everything would fit together later. Once the left side of the building was done I started on the far right, adding lights until the entire right facade was lit. I used this as my “right side” foundation for everything that followed, such as the grass and reflection image. Once all the compositional “puzzle pieces” and lighting were captured I was done for the evening.

Postproduction
Postproduction becomes quite simple if the lighting and captures were done well. In this case, I began with the initial dusk image and started laying in lighting in the order that the frames were shot. This gives me a starting point, something that I continue as I move through the image. Being that all the images were shot in 16-bit Raw on a 21-megapixel camera, I had a ton of flexibility. (Although I have that flexibility and do sometimes use it, I try to always use exposures that don’t need a whole lot of processing or correction.)

This is a quixotic look into just how complex you can get with this technique. When shooting and editing I had to really focus on what was actual and what was reflection. For me this one really boggles the mind.

During Raw conversion the images need to stay consistent in tone, color, and contrast; if not, no matter how much time you put into lighting, the final image will not look right. From there it was the simple but tedious task of using Layers to stack all the images, blending them with the previous shot. Once the images for this shot were roughed in using Layers (about three hours) then the blend and polish began.

When time allows, I normally let the layered image sit for about a week after the initial “rough-in” before I start the refinement process. This stage of the work consists of moving through the image and cleaning it up, starting with the largest problems and progressively working toward the detail areas. I can also modify the overall thrust of the image depending on how I feel. After several sessions of this type of work the image begins to emerge as the “dull haze of preproduction” is removed layer by layer until, hopefully, a brilliant stone emerges. This is quite exciting because sometimes I think I have an amazing image just to find that I have nothing to write home about, and there are others, which I have no hope for, that turn out to be spectacular.

Here’s a closer look at the exterior with a vertical detail.

All this freestyling might on the surface seem to go totally against the near Teutonic nature of architectural photography. When you have 50 variables, any of which could ruin a shot, the last thing you would want to do is add another 50, but that is exactly what makes this style so dynamic. It allows the photographer who takes care and applies skill in lighting as well as preproduction and postproduction planning to indulge in all the wondrous possibilities of the craft without having to make an enormous investment in lighting and associated gear.

About The Author
Mike Butler first learned the core concepts of photography 20 years ago in Bangkok, Thailand, where he photographed the Bangkok streets, where, as he says, “the exceptional was every day.” He has been engaged in architectural photography for 15 years where he has gained a reputation for a completely unique and technically complex style of shooting. Butler brings these years of deep technical understanding, avant-garde lighting, and keen compositional skills to bear on his commercial projects. When photographing personal projects, Butler adapts these highly structured commercial elements to more complex logistical scenes. Whether he is camping with generators and lighting at 13,000 feet to photograph ruins, shooting in -10˚F conditions, or traveling through the complex and dangerous streets of Third World countries, Butler is always pushing the aesthetic and technical envelope.

To see more of Butler’s amazing work, visit his website at: www.mike-butler.com.

COMMENTS
Keyla Dewal's picture

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I really feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you achieve experience, would you thoughts updating your blog with additional information? This can be very helpful for me.I'll use this information to provide research papers for my friends.

crossting's picture

had been looking for these information for long time, thanx for sharing! clip in feather extensions

lamperouge09's picture

A couple of of these may be acquired prefabricated & fit together on-site. They can could be moveable meaning these were designed on the pacquiao vs bradley structure that's capable of being drawn with a truck. The one thing that I like about the welding schools subject is always that these come in many unique shapes and dimensions and a lot of variations.

jason jeff's picture

Wow! An Excellent blog on Architectural Layers. Thanks for this useful information. acneproactivetreatments

jason jeff's picture

It’s really a nice and helpful piece of information. I’m glad that you shared this helpful info with us. get-rid-of-pimple

jason jeff's picture

i know i am a little off topic, but i just wanted to say i love the layout of your blog. dealwithpoppingpimples

CheskaFarr210's picture

Even though we sometimes lack of the so-called motivation in order for us to continue living the life that we wanna have, it's important that we still go on even if that happens. - David Slone

X