Q&A For Digita l Photography

Jill Rahn's picture
Digital Help is designed to aid you in getting the most from your digital photography, printing, scanning, and image creation. Each month, David Brooks provides solutions to problems you might encounter with matters such as color calibration and management, digital printer and scanner settings, and working with digital photographic images with many different kinds of cameras and software. All questions sent to him will be answered with the most appropriate information he can access and provide. However, not all questions and answers will appear in this department. Readers can send questions to David Brooks addressed to Shutterbug magazine, through the Shutterbug website (www.shutterbug.com), directly via e-mail to: editorial@shutterbug.com or goofotografx@gmail.com or by US Mail to: David Brooks, PO Box 2830, Lompoc, CA 93438.

To aid us in making Digital Help as helpful as possible, please be specific in your query and include components, including software, that you use. David says, “Make me guess the problem and I might guess wrong.”—Editor

UV Or Not To UV
Q. Does a UV filter degrade the quality of digital images? I have a UV haze filter on all my lenses, primarily to protect the lens. However, my daughter brought to my attention that “there is controversy that the extra piece of glass degrades the picture slightly by reducing contrast.” Is that true? Should I remove the filters, or not worry about it? Frankly, the filter has saved my lenses more than once.
Ralph Selitzer
via e-mail

A. It must be at least 30 years since I first argued this question, but old myths still persist. Most good lenses are sold with a lens cap of essentially unbreakable plastic, which is about the best physical protection there is for the front surface of a camera lens. Even the best filters made of optical glass will easily shatter into shards that, if forced against a lens element, will cut into the optical surface and can cause irreparable damage. However, in rare instances like photographing on a windy ocean beach, cleaning the salt spray off the front lens element afterward is not easily done. Well, I’ve only had to do that a handful of times in over 50 years of photography.
Selling glass filters as lens protection was in the old days a way to add to the profit of the sale of a lens or camera, and was indulged in by camera salespeople frequently and liberally. So the myth was born and grew into a system of belief, added to by the laziness of photographers who found it more convenient than removing and replacing a lens cap.
And yes, a flat glass filter element adds to surface light dispersion and refraction which will diminish contrast, a sometimes useful characteristic in the moviemaking industry used to reduce the exposed scene contrast to match a scene from day to day. Harrison & Harrison, makers of movie lens filters, had a whole set of different strengths of contrast reduction filters that were regularly used for this purpose. Your daughter is quite correct and accurate as far as optical functions are concerned.

Energy Efficient LCD Displays
Q. Thanks for your review of the Dell U2410. I found it very informative, especially since I’m in the process of buying a monitor that is suitable for photography. Have you found another monitor similarly priced, but a little bit more earth-friendly? Not that I believe that the Dell is not. It is just that I have seen many new devices that claim to be more environmental or energy efficient that could potentially be a better choice. I wonder if some of them may be RGB compliant within the same price range.
Mario Burgos
via e-mail

A. The easy answer for me is no. Although some brands like ASUS and ViewSonic claim their “photography” pro-graphics models work for this purpose, I have tested them and they do not meet the standards set by the pro-graphics models I have recommended. The Dell UltraSharp U2410 does work, although quite a few readers report that they have received defective units, but Dell has immediately replaced them. It is still at least $500 less expensive than a 24” NEC SpectraView, or a 24” EIZO FlexScan SX, or my favorite, the LaCie 324i. None of these have an LED backlight that uses less electricity. But LED is not ideal or recommended for photographic use, and all LED displays are limited to sRGB color range. The LaCie 324i has an adjustable backlight and lowering the backlight level should reduce the energy consumption.

All Digital Images Are In Color
Q. My friend is scanning black-and-white negatives to make digital negatives on Pictorico Transparency film for platinum printing. He is planning to buy an iMac and I mentioned your recommendation to use the Mac mini with a pro-graphics display, but he thought that would only apply to color printing. Would the iMac display be suitable in this case or for printing black and white only?
Terence Morrissey
via e-mail

A. All the displays currently available are RGB color and only display color. When a grayscale file is sent to the display the red, green, and blue pixels are all activated, but with the same numerical value for each color, so the image appears to be gray even though it is an RGB color image.
To reproduce an image file on any printing media, including Pictorico Transparency, the display has to be adjusted in brightness/white luminance to match paper white. And that is about 80.0 to 90.0 CD/m2 white luminance. As it is delivered, the iMac screen will not adjust to a screen brightness that matches paper white for “print” output using the available display management hardware and software. I have heard that the latest X-Rite i1Display Pro may work, but no one has reported using it effectively with a new iMac.
The Mac mini I tested and use is now working in my lab with a Dell UltraSharp U2410 LCD display and both together at US list prices cost $1398, and the Dell U2410 reproduces the Adobe RGB color range and will easily adjust to the 80.0 CD/m2 equivalent of paper white.
The iMac with AMD Radeon video is $1499 for the 21.5” and $1699 for the 27”, and both only have an sRGB color range. The bottom line is that the technology applies the same to grayscale or color printing, and the same adjustment, calibration, and profiling of the display is required. With the iMac it is very difficult to accomplish and you still only see two-thirds of the image information displayed on screen.
I know and can recommend that a Mac mini like the one I reported on and a Dell UltraSharp U2410 will work. With an iMac it may be made to work, but still has display limitations that do not support serious digital photography.

Printer Change Is Due
Q. I have had my Epson R1800 for almost seven years. I print 13x19” prints and have generally been very, very pleased with the results, although the machine can be temperamental at unpredictable times.
Recently I have been consuming vast quantities of ink doing multiple head cleanings because the nozzle check pattern reveals white lines and gaps, and my prints have been blotchy in some areas. I have not been able to resolve the problem. Do you know what might be causing the problem? Is it time to get rid of the R1800? If so, do you have any recommendations in the $600 range? (For example, Adorama is selling the Epson R3000 for $599 after a $200 rebate.)
David A. Bradlow
via e-mail

A. Well, mechanical things like a print head in a printer do eventually wear out, which is likely what you described. I used an R800 that is a smaller letter-sized version of the same printer you have, and eventually it wore out, too. I replaced it with an R1900, which I am still using with good satisfaction. Recently I tested an Epson R2000, and found it produced prints very much like my old R800 and newer R1900, and somewhat better, and worked extremely well. If my R1900 needs replacing I will likely get an R2000.
I have had an Epson R2880 and it was never consistent and did not reproduce prints I liked as much as the R1900 and has not been at all reliable, so it went back in its box sometime ago where it remains. The R3000 is the same general CMYK ink set printer design, so I was not interested in even trying it when it came out. I would recommend an Epson R2000 if you want a good replacement for your R1800.

Options For The Mac mini
Q. Thank you for your Mac mini review in the April,
2012, issue, and indeed for all your work at Shutterbug. You’ve made a few comments in recent issues about the downsides of the iMac as a photographer’s display, and those, coupled with this Mac mini review, have tilted me
in favor of the mini.
I have two questions: 1) You said you preferred the OWC Mercury Pro CD/DVD drive to Apple’s USB external SuperDrive, but did not state why. Could you say a few words about that? 2) I appreciated your review of the EIZO FlexScan SX2262W display, but it is a tad above my budget. Do you have any recommendations for an IPS monitor in the $300 or so range?
Bill Amatneek
via e-mail

A. First of all, the Apple CD/DVD drive is a compact, lightweight unit like the units put into computers. The Mercury Pro is a heavier, more substantial and more reliable professional production drive. I do a lot of disc burning and the drives they put into computers, whether Apple or other PC brands, are lightweight units that will not last long if used very much for disc burning.
Second, if you want a $300 display you cannot afford a computer that will accurately edit and process digital photography. The 27” Apple Thunderbolt display that is the same as in the iMac is only sRGB color and won’t do the job. The cheapest LCD display that will work is the 24” Dell UltraSharp U2410 and it lists at $599. (I got mine from Dell when it was advertised at $100 off.)
The only way around this is to shoot sRGB/JPEG digital camera photos, and don’t edit them, just take them as you get them as edited by the camera. Then it does not matter what kind of computer you use.

80.0 Or 90.0 CD/m2?
Q. I read your article on the X-Rite i1Display Pro in the December, 2011, issue but noted your reservations regarding small type on high-res screens and the lack of a setting for luminance at 90.0. The price you mentioned was $269.
Although you had concerns about the X-Rite not having a setting for 90.0, you didn’t say whether or how that affected your results, e.g., were your prints off from the display? If so, did you develop an adjustment or workaround to get the prints to match the display?
Do you have any info or opinions on a new product, the Spyder4Pro—it’s $169 ($100 less than the X-Rite)? Can it be set to a luminance of 90.0? Any thoughts about it versus the X-Rite? Any other colorimeter/software products out there that you like better these days?
Jim
via e-mail

A. Because of queries like yours I requested a tryout of the new Datacolor Spyder4Elite and the company was kind enough to send me one to test. It works, and the complications with the last versions of Expert Console and CALcheck have been incorporated into an easier workflow; however, it lacks the Automatic Display Control in the X-Rite i1Display Pro. Seeing the results and using the new Spyder4Elite did not change my preference for the X-Rite i1Display Pro.
I have used the new X-Rite i1Display Pro for a while now, and setting the white luminance at 80.0 CD/m2 is not any real disadvantage, and the X-Rite system works well and is easy to use. The difference between 80.0 and 90.0 CD/m2 is inconsequential, as 80.0 is the recommended setting for prepress and 90.0 is what most CRT monitors produce. In addition, I recently checked the selling price of the i1Display Pro on Google Shopping and it can be purchased for as little as $211. So it would be my choice if I needed to buy a new display management system of colorimeter and software.

ANNOUNCEMENT
I am pleased to announce the latest 4.3 Edition to my eBook Digital Darkroom Resource CD. The CD now contains 33 chapters totaling 399 pages in Adobe Acrobat .PDF format, providing easy-to-read text and large high-quality illustration. The CD is available for $20 plus $5 shipping and handling (US Mail if available). Ordering is as simple as sending a check or money order for $25 made out to me, David B. Brooks, and mailed to PO Box 2830, Lompoc, CA 93438.

Share | |
Comments
texas best's picture
topes de estacionamiento

I really like this article. It contains a lot of useful information. I can set up my new idea from this post. It gives in depth information. topes de estacionamiento

quora30's picture
I'm quite glad to have seen

I'm quite glad to have seen this blog, thank you so much for all the great information on cameras and wonderful pictures, I'll be sure to pass the url on to my more artistic family and friends
Margahayuland | Margahayuland | Yurosie | ide bagus

quora30's picture
He he! This is funny! I would

He he! This is funny! I would love to have an essay describing yourself with these guys. I guess it will never be boring at classes. I wonder how a rap song about the extinction of dinosaurs would be. Cari Uang Lewat Ekiosku.com, Cipto Junaedy.BOLA368.com Agen Judi Bola Terpercaya Promo 10% all Games Sportbook

seoindia's picture
Re: Hello Friends

   I was very pleased to find this site. I wanted to thank you for
this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have
you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. 
Led Strip Lights
Led Strip Light
12V Led Lights
Indoor Led Strip Lights
Outdoor Led Strip Lights
12V Transformers
Led tea lights candles
Rechargeable tea lights candles
Colour changing led candles
LED FLICKERING TEA LIGHT CANDLES
Led Power Supplies
LED Transformers
Led Connectors
Led Gu10 lights
Led G4 Lights
Led Mr16 lights
Led Mr11 Lights
Transformer for LED Lights
LED Rope Lights
LED Sticker Lights
Dental Tourism
Laser Hair Removal
conservatory prices
diy conservatory
diy conservatories
conservatories prices
lean to conservatory
lean to conservatories
self build conservatories
self build conservatories
self build conservatory
jungian analysis
jungian analyst jungian
analysis new york jungian analyst new york
carl jung analysis
carl jung analysis new york carl
jung psychotherapy carl jung therapy
carl jung therapy new york
jungian therapy
jungian therapy new york jungian
dream interpretation jungian psychotherapy
jungians
dealing with a narcissist
dealing with
narcissistic personality
definition of
narcissistic healing narcissism
living with a narcissist
meaning of narcissistic
narcissism
narcissism and healing
narcissism and
therapy narcissistic behavior
narcissistic dad
narcissistic father
narcissistic father/mother
narcissistic mom
narcissistic mother
narcissistic parent
narcissistic person
narcissistic personality
narcissistic personality disorder in
relationships narcissistic symptoms
narcissistic women
narcissistic men
therapy for narcissism
SEO INDIA
SEO INDIA
SEO INDIA COMPANY
SEO INDIA
security systems chicago
security cameras chicago
cctv installations chicago
billing software
quotation software
billing
software, quotation software

SEO Service India offering economical and affordable
SEO COMPANY INDIA services to clients worldwide.
Best Seo Company India
Cheapest SEO India
Affordable SEO India
White Hat SEO India
Ethical SEO Services India
capoeira beginners sydney
capoeira western suburbs
martial arts sydney
capoeira classes sydney
capoeira australia
capoeira sydney
learn capoeira sydney
capoeira kids sydney

SEO COMPANY INDIA
SEO INDIA
SEO EXPERTS INDIA
SEO COMPANY INDIA
SEO INDIA
SEO EXPERTS INDIA

alarm system takeover
alarm system take over
chicago no contract
alarm monitoring
cheap alarm monitoring central vacuum systems
central vacuum systems
installations
residential intercom systems
commercial intercom
systems apartment
building intercom systems
flat screen tv
installations hang
lcd tv tv installations
chicago in-wall speaker
installations multi
room sound installations
projector room
installations
surround sound wiring surround
sound wiring chicago
home theater wiring new
construction low voltage wiring
new construction
low voltage wiring chicago
new home prewire
residential network wiring
alarm system
home security systems chicago
security systems
alarm systems apartment
security cameras
chicago apartment
security systems
chicago retail security
system
chicago bank security and surveillance
chicago school security
cameras
security system
adt alarm chicago
adt home security chicago
security systems chicago
wireless home alarms
chicago
chicago land surveillance system home security
adt security
chicago security business
home theater
chicago
chicago suburb surveillance and security
video surveillance
chicago
cctv camera chicago
chicago community
surveillance systems
cctv installations
chicago
chicago office security systems
Bitcoin Casino
surveillance camera
systems chicago
home surveillance system
chicago video
surveillance systems chicago
surveillance camera
system chicago
wireless surveillance
system chicago
home surveillance systems
chicago video
surveillance system chicago
surveillance system chicago
home alarm systems
chicago home alarm
systems
chicago security system
surveillance systems
chicago
home alarm systems chicago
security cameras
chicago
chicago home security systems
chicago security cameras
security camera chicago
house alarm systems
chicago home
theater
home security system chicago
security system chicago
residential camera
systems chicago security
cameras chicago
chicago security systems
home theater
systems chicago
SEO Service India
SEO COMPANY INDIA
Best Seo Company India
Cheapest SEO India
Affordable SEO India
White Hat SEO India
Ethical SEO Services India

Men designer shoes Nigeria
Women dresses Nigeria
Women fashion accessories Nigeria
Indian Costumes Nigeria
Women lace bodycon dresses
Men designer Sneakers Nigeria
Women designer bags Nigeria
Women Leather bags Nigeria
Women underwears Nigeria Football
Jerseys Nigeria Long evening gown
Nigeria Indian fashion materials Nigeria
Original Peruvian Hair Nigeria
Original Supra Sneakers Nigeria
Women Fashion colar necklace Nigeria
Authentic women clothes Lagos Nigeria Indian
Wedding Suits Lagos Nigeria Ethnic
Fabrics Lagos Nigeria Cheap Women
Leather Bags Nigeria Branded Hobo bags
Nigeria Plus size women shoes
Nigeria Plus size women clothes Nigeria
Plus Size women fashion costumes Nigeria
Ladies shoes Nigeria
Wedding ring Nigeria
Bitcoin,
Casino,
Gambling,
Gaming,Dice
Men Suits Nigeria
Women corporate wears Nigeria
Women short dresses Party Dress Nigeria
Maxi dress Nigeria

billing
software,
quotation software
cambridge,
cambridge guide, cambridge travel,
hotels in cambridge,visit cambridge,
Arlington Heights Security Systems
Laser Hair Removal Delhi
Hair
Transplant Delhi
muskelaufbau
kreatin
creatine creatin kaufen
arginin
l'arginin maca
potenzmittel
natuerliche potenzmittel
acai
acai beere acai diaet
acai 6000
moringa
moringa kapseln moringa pulver
Web Design Dublin
Web Design Galway
Web Design Cork
SEO Company Ireland
Web Design Ireland
Web Design Company
Web Design Donegal
Web Design Sligo
Web Design Athlone
Web Design Northern Ireland
Web Design Ireland
Ecommerce web design
Online Shop Design
Web Design Cavan SEO
Ireland
jquery sliderr
responsive sliderr
content sliderr
image sliderr
jquery carouseljquery carousel 
profumi,
profumeria  Handy
Reparatur Bremen   Iphone
Display Reparatur Bremen
Iphone 5 Display Reparatur
Samsung Galaxy S3 Display Reparatur
Samsung Galaxy S4 Display
Reparatur Ipad Display
Reparatur Ipod 5 Display
Reparatur Htc Handy
Display Reparatur Iphone 4
Display Reparatur Handy
Reparatur Service Samsung
Galaxy S2 Display Reparatur
Apple Iphone 5 Display Glas Reparatur
Htc One Display Reparatur
Samsung S3 LTE I9305 Display
Reparatur Iphone Display
Reparatur Bremen
personalized baby gifts
baby gifts
baby gift baskets  unique
baby gifts baby blankets
baby towels

 profumi, 
profumeria 
Mobile app development singapore,
android app development singapore, iOS app
development singapore ,

Mobile app development malaysia,
android app development malaysia,
iphone app development Malaysia,
ipad app development Malaysia,
ios app development malaysia,
beauty
salon delhi,
app development company malaysia,
leadmotion malaysia ,
beauty
parlour delhi , Minibus hire Glasgow
Minibus hire in Glasgow
Coach hire Glasgow
Coach hire in Glasgow
Glasgow minibus hire
Glasgow coach hire
Minibus hire Glasgow
airport Minibus hire Glasgow with driver
 Minibus hire  Coach
hire Bus hire Glasgow
16 seater minibus hire Glasgow
Glasgow bus hire
Wedding coach hire Glasgow 
geburtskarten ,
geburtskarten online ,
geburtsanzeigen ,
geburtskarten selber gestalten ,
geburtskarte selber machen,
danksagungskarten , einladungskarten ,
fotokarten ,
fotokarten selber gestalten ,
babykarten ,
hochzeitskarten ,
hochzeitskarten online gestalten ,
karten drucken ,
geburtstagseinladung online gestalten ,
geburtstagskarte   tshirts 
, t-shirt   ,
 t-shirts  ,shirt
kaufen  , t-shirt kaufen  ,
t-shirt druck  , t-shirt bedrucken ,
t-shirt gestalten ,
 t-shirt selber gestalten ,
.t-shirt selber machen ,
.t-shirt online shop ,
t-shirt online gestalten ,
t-shirt online designen , t-shirt drucken
online  , t-shirt design
extensões de unhas 
o melhor curso de unhas
gel de construção
cursos de unhas de gel
produtos para unhas 
unhas
fashion nails
emprego
fulfillment services
3rd party logistics  fulfillment
service online fulfillment
fulfillment company
e commerce fulfillment
product fulfillment
chicago fulfillment
fulfillment companies 
fulfillment and distribution  midwest
fulfillment fulfillment houses
order fulfillment
fulfillment center pack and
ship logistics wine fulfillment
 fulfillment house
parcel shipping
international shipping
third party logistics
fulfillment warehousing
wine shipping
supply chain management
illinois fulfillment
adwords management company
seo company reading
seo company berkshire 
pay per click company
 mobile website design 
bee scorecard
scorecard bee
bee and bbbee compliancy
bbbee compliancy
bee scorecards in south africa 
bee
bbbee  
bee certification
bee certificates
bee consultants  SEO
COMPANY SEARCH ENGINE OPTINMIZATION 
SEO SERVICES 
BEST SEO COMPANY
INTERNET MARKETING
hong kong escort
hong kong escorts
escort hk
hk escort
escort hong kong
escort in hong kong
hong kong escort in service
hong kong escort agency
the best hong kong escort
escort hong kong service
hong kong massage service
hong kong escort massage
escort service hong kong
escort massage service hong kong
hongkong escorts

zeta1's picture
Tapetes con diseño

If at all possible, while you acquire info, remember to add to this website together with brand new info.Tapetes con diseño

zeta1's picture
custom logo mats

It provided me a few ideas and I’ll be posting them on my web site eventually. I’m bookmarking your site and I’ll be back again.custom logo mats

cherrin's picture
ahappydeal

Save 30-60% at REI-OUTLET on top-name Discount Outdoor Gear and clothing. Deals, discounts and bargains for camping, hiking, cycling, skiing, kayaking and more.

online buying selling's picture
online buying selling

Trading zone where you can do entire trading, buy and sell, us trade | online selling Many people extract lot of experience during this online buying selling | online selling platform, many other think about this is a foreign exchange | online buying center, but it is wrong because it is a uk trade Like online selling

Presented by: seo learning

sultan's picture
Your knowledge of this

Your knowledge of this subject comes through clearly in this article. I love to read this kind of articles, I hope you will update it. Thank you for sharing it with me. www.outdoordaybed.net/

sultan's picture
Your post is very

Your post is very informative. It really helped me learn something new. Thanks for sharing it with us. http://woodenfurnitures.net/do-i-want-an-oak-tv-unit/

richar1122's picture
Your music is amazing. You

Your music is amazing. You have some very talented artists. I wish you the best of success.
magicseosolution

MariaW's picture
Previously, photos were

Previously, photos were considered an art form. In the arsenal of the photographer had little funds to work with photography. Modern Photography is a technology and special effects.

platform shoes
high heels shoes
prom shoes girls
pink shoes
wine accessories
310 shoes

fawadhussain1212's picture
Find good quality and

Find good quality and reliable supplier for China mobile phones, cell phones,smart phones.
KimK Superstar

reshhia's picture
Some individuals really make

Some individuals really make distinction. I completely believe the fact with the factor of the writer. We should all enhance this weblog.world war boards motocrossvideos.net

Amirali's picture
sometimes useful

sometimes useful characteristic in the movie making industry used to reduce the exposed scene contrast to match a scene from day to day. pėrsonal injury attorney lawyėr

Tommy123's picture
All the contents you

All the contents you mentioned in post are too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts.
software developer company

Richard M. Fairbanks's picture
Digita l Photography

Digital photography uses an array of electronic photodetectors to capture the image focused by the lens, as opposed to an exposure on photographic film. The captured image is then digitized and stored as a computer file ready for digital processing, viewing, digital publishing or printing. http://virilityhealth.vitamine-und-mehr.org/

gangamani's picture
Corporate Gift

Corporate Gift --Gangamani Fashions has gained prominence as manufacturer, exporter and supplier of corporate gifts items. We are one of Indian Unique Corporate Gifts suppliers.
http://www.indianethnicgifts.com/corporate-gifts