Cave Photography; Color, Gear, And Light Painting, Underground Style Page 2
HDR In The Caverns
I was excited to try out the HDR (High Dynamic Range) ability of Photoshop CS3 after photographing in Carlsbad Caverns earlier this year. It is designed to create photographs that have detail in both shadows and highlights, even when the scene being photographed has contrast beyond the capability of the camera. The HDR feature layers several photographs together that have been exposed so that at least one frame has details in the shadows and another frame has details in the highlights. As instructed by the Photoshop manual, I made several exposures of the same scene, bracketing heavily, and then let Photoshop do its thing back in the office. The resulting photographs were technically very good, but I still prefer the photos where I took my time to paint in the shadows.
Another characteristic of cave lighting that needs to be considered is color. Most caves I've visited are lit by mixed sources, that is, the cave is lit by more than one type of bulb. Daylight-balanced film is made to look "right" outside in, well, daylight. Artificial lights, however, don't necessarily have the same characteristics as daylight. Common fluorescent lights are green, incandescent lights are yellow, mercury-vapor can vary while the new LED lights I've seen seem pretty close to daylight or even a little blue.
When using film, it would be best to carry CC (Color Correction) filters for each kind of light. Unfortunately, more than one type of light often ends up in a composition, and then the decision has to be made as to which color to correct. I normally didn't use a CC filter, but I lost a few nice compositions because the color was just so awful, which illustrates another major advantage of digital capture. I now shoot in raw with the camera set on "Auto White Balance." The white balance can then be tweaked in Photoshop and, even in the most difficult mixed lighting, this has worked splendidly.
Papoose Room, Carlsbad Caverns National Park, New Mexico
A good tripod is mandatory since exposures are typically 20-90 seconds, and using a cable release or the camera's self-timer is best. The lithium battery-powered flashlight I use is available at many sporting goods stores for under $40, is surprisingly bright for its size, and provides a pleasing neutral color. My recent camera of choice is the Canon EOS-1Ds Mark II with Canon's 24-105mm "L" IS lens and a Canon 70-200mm "L" lens. I put all this equipment, along with a few extra camera batteries and CompactFlash cards, in a collapsible cooler made to hold a six-pack. The cooler is much lighter than my standard bag, is easier to carry through passageways, and, since water is an important ingredient in the cave-forming process, provides a barrier between my equipment and cave moisture. Except for the flashlight, all this equipment is the same as what I use above ground.
So now I have you excited to find a cave and give photography in the dark a try, right? But where? The good news is there are about 200 show caves and caverns (caves developed for public visitation) in the US, and each one is different. I recommend starting close to where you live, and for me that's Mystery Cave (in Forestville/Mystery Cave State Park) and Niagara Cave--which has a waterfall and beautiful formations--both in southern Minnesota. To find show caves near you, contact the National Caves Association at: www.cavern.com (phone: 270-749-2228). Type in your zip code on the website and you'll get a long list of caves in order of distance from you.
Always contact the cave before visiting to find out their policies regarding photography and tripods.
If you're traveling, or lucky enough to live nearby, I highly recommend visiting Carlsbad Caverns and Mammoth Cave National Parks. Carlsbad Caverns has self-guided tours which allow tripods.
On these tours photographers can take their time and set up in one area for as long as desired. I've spent hours traveling just a few hundred yards. The formations are beautiful and you can enjoy the Big Room, the largest natural limestone cavern in the Western Hemisphere. Find out more about Carlsbad Caverns at: www.nps.gov/cave/ (phone: 505-785-2232).
Mammoth Cave is the longest cave system in the world with mapped passages exceeding 360 miles. Some of these passages are huge open corridors while others are narrow twisting canyons. Being a dry cave, Mammoth lacks most of the intricate decorations seen in other caves, although the areas known as Frozen Niagara and the Drapery Room are notable exceptions. The Park Service offers a special tour to these decorated features called the "Focus on Formations" tour which is designed specifically for photographers. This tour is the only tour at Mammoth Cave where tripods are allowed, and at the time of this writing, it was being offered on weekend evenings, but the schedule is subject to change, so check with the Park at: www.nps.gov/maca/ (phone: 270-758-2180).
I greatly enjoy visiting caves and, while I tour more often without my camera than with, when I do get the opportunity to take the camera and tripod underground, I relish the challenge of photographing such a unique form of nature.
When Clint Farlinger's not totally in the dark, he can be found photographing nature throughout the US. More of his photos can be seen at: www.agpix.com/farlinger.